Paid
Time-Off Benefits Hold Steady During Recession
July
2009
When designing a competitive and
comprehensive total rewards plan, it is important to consider
the value of paid time-off benefits to employees and the cost to
your organization.
Results from
a 2009
Culpepper Benefits Survey
on paid time-off programs reveals that some companies have
curtailed their paid time-off benefits in response to the
economic downturn. However, most companies have protected their
paid time-off benefits to help retain high-performing employees
and key talent.
Key Findings
-
Approximately two-thirds of
companies use a traditional paid time-off model
with days allocated to specific
categories (e.g., holiday, vacation, sick, personal).
-
Nearly one-third of companies
use a PTO bank model with a pool of paid time-off days.
-
17% of companies allow
employees to cash out unused vacation and PTO days.
-
19% of companies implemented
a furlough and/or reduction-in-hours
within the last
twelve months.
-
15% of companies are planning
or considering a furlough and/or reduction-in-hours
within the next six to twelve months.
Types of Paid Time-Off Models Used
Most paid time-off benefit plans in the U.S. fit into two
categories (Figure 1):
-
Traditional Paid Time-Off
Models with days allocated to specific categories
(e.g., holiday, vacation, sick/personal leave).*
- PTO Bank Models combining holidays, vacation,
sick, and personal days into one pool, allowing employees to
take time off for any reason.*

Approximately one percent of participants reported a flexible
paid time-off model that allows employees to take paid vacation,
sick, and personal time on an “as needed basis” without
specifying a specific number of days.
* Regardless of the type of paid time-off model, many
companies have separate polices for the following types of time
not worked: family/medical leave, short-term disability, jury
duty, testifying in court as a witness, military leave and reserve
duty, sabbaticals, and voting. Legal statutes in some states
require companies to pay employees for jury duty, testifying in
court as a witness, and voting.
Traditional Paid Time-Off Models
Traditional paid-time off models typically take one of two
forms:
-
Traditional Paid Time-Off
Model with a specified number of sick &
personal days
About four-out-of-five companies define a specific number of
paid sick and personal days that may be taken each year
(Table 1).
-
Traditional Paid Time-Off
Model without a specified number of sick &
personal days
Approximately one-fifth of companies do not define a
specific number of paid sick and personal days that may be
taken each year (Table 1). Instead, most of these companies
describe having flexible sick and personal leave policies
that allow employees to take paid sick and/or personal
time-off off on an as needed basis.
Table 1: Average Number of Days of Paid Time-Off for
Traditional Models |
|
Avg # Sick & Personal Days |
Avg # Holidays |
Avg # Vacation Days by Number of Years of Employment |
|
Designated |
Floating |
1 Year |
3 Years |
5 Years |
10 Years |
15 Years |
20 Years |
|
With
specified number of Sick & Personal Days |
|
7.6 |
8.9 |
1.2 |
11.5 |
12.8 |
15.7 |
18.7 |
20.3 |
21.1 |
|
Without
specified number of Sick & Personal Days |
|
n/a |
9.0 |
1.1 |
14.2 |
14.7 |
17.5 |
19.6 |
21.3 |
21.6 |
|
* Additional statistical metrics and data cuts are
available in the comprehensive version of this report. |
PTO Bank Models
PTO bank models combine holidays, vacation, sick, and personal
days into one pool, allowing employees to take time off for any
reason (Table 2). Nearly one-third of companies with paid
time-off benefits use a PTO bank model.
Table 2: PTO Bank Model with Pool of Paid Time-Off Days |
Average # Days in PTO Pool
by Number of Years of Employment |
|
1 Year |
3 Years |
5 Years |
10 Years |
15 Years |
20 Years |
|
17.3 |
18.6 |
21.5 |
24.7 |
25.4 |
25.9 |
|
* Additional statistical metrics and data cuts are
available in the comprehensive version of this report. |
Other Paid
Time-Off Practices & Policies
In addition
to the data table and figure above, we provide a more
comprehensive report with additional information and data tables
covering the following:
-
Number of Paid
Time-Off Days
-
Eligibility to
Receive Paid Time-Off Benefits
-
Paid Time-Off
Provided to Part-Time Employees
-
Eligibility to Take
Paid Time-Off
-
Paid Time-Off
Accrual Schedules
-
Treatment of Unused
Vacation and PTO Days
(Accrual Maximums, Carry Forward/Roll Over,
and Cash Out Practices & Policies)
-
Mini-Vacations
-
Donating, Buying,
and Selling of Vacation and PTO Days
-
Unlimited Paid
Leave Plans
-
Sabbaticals &
Extended Leave Programs
Demographic
data cuts include:
-
Number
of Employees
(1 to 100, 101 to 500, 501 to 2,500, Over
2,500)
-
Industry Sector
(Technology, Life Sciences)
-
Ownership
(Public, Private, Non-Profit)
Availability of Comprehensive Report as Downloadable PDF

-
Free to participants in
2009 Paid Time-Off Practices & Policies Survey
-
Free to subscribers of
Culpepper Benefits Survey
Package
(includes Culpepper Library and Small
Company Plus subscribers)
-
$295 for non-participants and non-subscribers (Order
Form)
Data Source: Culpepper Benefits Survey of
182 organizations.
Survey Dates: April 13 through June 9, 2009
Breakdown by Sector:
Technology 60%, Life Sciences 14%, Other 26%
Participant
Breakdown by Number of Employees: Up to 100: 30%, 101 to
500: 29%, 501 to 2,500: 25%, Over 2,500:
15%
Participant Breakdown
by Ownership/Corporate Status: Public 32%, Private 58%, Non-Profit
6%,
Government 2%
Participant Breakdown by Country: United
States 98%, Canada 2%
Copying. If you decide to copy portions of
this article into your own publication or transmission, please
cite your source by including the following: "Source: Culpepper
Benefits Surveys, July 2009,
www.culpepper.com"
|
|
|
Stay informed of current market trends and practices for compensation programs.
Subscribe to our FREE monthly Culpepper eBulletin e-mail newsletter.
|